natural gas field

Nord Stream 2 “useless and illegal”, say environment experts

Europe’s newest gas pipeline is a threat to people and wildlife, environment charities have warned. The experts say the dangers the project poses to the environment make it illegal under European climate and environment laws – and it should under no circumstances go ahead.

In comments on the Environmental Impact Assessment for Nord Stream 2, which will transport natural gas from Russia to Germany, ClientEarth and Greenpeace point out that the work violates EU laws on air quality, climate and habitat conservation.

The planned pipeline will pass near Natura 2000 conservation sites in eight EU countries, including two in Poland: Zatoka Pomorska and Ostoja na Zatoce Pomorskiej.

ClientEarth’s Marcin Stoczkiewicz explained: “According to the EU’s Habitats Directive, every new investment in the vicinity of a Natura 2000 site, which may have a significant impact on that site, must be subjected to adequate assessment.

“The Environmental Impact Assessment for the Nord Stream 2 project doesn’t provide for a reliable impact assessment on Baltic Sea flora and fauna. For that reason we are calling on the Finnish authorities to refuse to issue an environmental permit. All other EU member states should do likewise.”

Natural gas – a sensible investment?

The charities also questioned the economic sense of the investment.

Robert Cyglicki, director of Greenpeace Poland, said: “Nord Stream 2 is a useless and harmful investment by companies that want to force dependency on fossil fuels at any cost.

“Law has been amended at the behest of these companies and a blind eye has been turned to the reliability of the Environmental Impact Assessment. That’s why we are demanding a full assessment of the social and environmental costs of the Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline.”

Estimates show that by adopting a 40% greenhouse gas emissions reduction target, the EU will reduce its natural gas import by 13% to 2030 and by 27% to 2050. Adoption of renewable energy and energy efficiency targets would lead to further reduction of gas imports – down by up to 54% by 2050.

Share this...
Share on Facebook! Tweet this! Share on LinkedIn! Email!

Skitterphoto

Related articles

More from or

  • Jan Szyszko

    Polish minister who ordered illegal logging of Bialowieza Forest dismissed

    Poland’s environment minister Jan Szyszko has been dismissed from his job. He was responsible for ordering a three-fold increase in logging in Bialowieza Forest – which ClientEarth and other environmental groups have fought.

  • winter

    2017: A big year for Białowieża Forest – and the battle to protect it

    We started 2017 determined to do all we could to help save one of the most precious forests in Europe, the ancient Białowieża Forest.

  • Bison to illustrate story about final EU court hearing on illegal logging in Bialowieza Forest

    Highest EU Court hears Bialowieza illegal logging case, hopefully for the last time

    The hearing that took place today at the Court of Justice of the EU should finally decide whether Polish environment minister Jan Szyszko broke the law when he allowed increased logging in Białowieża Forest. The verdict is expected in early 2018.

  • Poland, bison, and exemptions from nature protection laws

    ClientEarth is challenging two decisions allowing the killing of up to 40 bison in Eastern Poland. The European bison, an extremely rare animal, is under strict protection.

  • Follow us

    You can help

    Your support helps us use the law to protect your environment.