Click 'Continue' if you consent to use all non-essential cookies.
Press release: 17 December 2020
EU environment ministers today agreed a position on access to justice that could jeopardise Europe’s efforts to lead by the rule of law and deliver the European Green Deal, say ClientEarth lawyers.
The EU is currently revising its access to justice law to increase the possibilities to challenge environmental wrongdoings in EU courts. This follows a decade-long battle led by ClientEarth to bring the EU into compliance with the Aarhus Convention – an international treaty on environmental democracy the EU has been breaching for over a decade.
ClientEarth welcomes the move to amend the Aarhus Regulation. But the reform proposed by the Commission contains significant loopholes and falls short of meeting the international standards laid out in the Aarhus Convention. The EU’s position, agreed today with minimum discussion by ministers in the Environment Council, missed the opportunity to remedy these shortcomings.
The draft law in its current state could still prevent people and NGOs from requesting review of numerous EU decisions that violate environmental law, like State aid to the fossil fuel industry or authorisations of controversial pesticides like glyphosate.
Lawyers at ClientEarth have criticised the ‘rushed’ decision, which fails to take into account the forthcoming advice from the UN body responsible for compliance with the Aarhus Convention.
ClientEarth Environmental democracy lawyer Anne Friel said: “The Council has rushed to adopt its position without introducing the amendments that could have greatly improved access to justice at EU level and finally brought the EU into compliance with international law.
“This is all the more disappointing as the Council itself made a very exceptional move in pushing the Commission to bring forward this legislative proposal with the stated objective of complying with the Aarhus Convention. The UN Aarhus Committee will issue advice imminently on whether the proposal would bring the EU into compliance with international law but the Council has appeared to decide it does not need this input.
“Access to justice is crucial to holding institutions accountable and making sure environmental law is not violated. This is an essential condition for the delivery of the EU Green Deal.
“It is now up to the European Parliament to correct the shot and introduce the necessary amendments. The Council, meanwhile, must be ready to revise its position when the Aarhus committee issue their guidance, as expressed by several member states during the meeting today.”
The European Parliament has now named a rapporteur for this file, which will be debated in the Environment committee in April before a vote in plenary session in May.
A 20-year journey towards access to justice - timeline:
ClientEarth is a charity that uses the power of the law to protect people and the planet. We are international lawyers finding practical solutions for the world’s biggest environmental challenges. We are fighting climate change, protecting oceans and wildlife, making forest governance stronger, greening energy, making business more responsible and pushing for government transparency. We believe the law is a tool for positive change. From our offices in London, Brussels, Warsaw, Berlin and Beijing, we work on laws throughout their lifetime, from the earliest stages to implementation. And when those laws are broken, we go to court to enforce them.