Photo of fishing nets to illustrate story about overfishing rise underestimated by Commission reliance on out of date information

Overfishing rise underestimated as Commission uses out of date information

The Commission’s new report on fishing opportunities claims 31 out of 59 stocks (53%) were fished sustainably (in accordance with Maximum Sustainable Yield) in 2014, compared to 32 out of 62 stocks (52%) in 2013.

However, the Commission made this comparison using out of date information, as the scientific report it uses has updated its numbers on the basis of new data. This is not reflected in the Commission’s report, which should have compared this year’s percentage – 52% – to the most up to date percent of stocks that were fished sustainably in 2013, which was actually 56%.

The report covers 2003 to 2014, when there was a big decline in overfishing. However, the most up to date information shows even more stocks were fished unsustainably in 2014 compared to 2013, instead of the ‘considerable’ decline in the rate of overfishing that the Commission reports.

Overfishing rise underestimated while unsustainable fishing tolerated

The European Commission and Council of Ministers have been complicit in breaching EU fisheries law by allowing overfishing to continue almost three years after the reformed Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) said this must be stopped as soon as possible.

The Commission’s 2014 proposal for managing fisheries in the Baltic Sea breached EU law by allowing fishing above the sustainable level required by the CFP. The Council of Ministers went even further, proposing even greater flexibility to overfish with scant regard for fisheries law or sound science.

The Council has failed to limit fishing to sustainable levels in many fisheries, without providing the evidence required to justify its decisions. A Freedom of Information request was required to see the Council’s ‘evidence’. The FoI proved that the data behind the decisions was weak and legally unsound.


Share this...
Share on Facebook! Tweet this! Share on LinkedIn! Email!


Related articles

More from

  • Fishing boat at sunset for story saying Commission 2018 fishing quotas risk missing legal sustainability deadline

    Commission’s 2018 fishing quotas risk missing legal sustainability deadline

    Many of the Commission’s proposed 2018 Northeast Atlantic fishing quotas move in the right direction, but the EU is still likely to miss 2020 deadline for sustainable fishing.

  • yellow and green flowers with fishing boat on sea

    Half-hearted sanctions against illegal fishing threaten Europe’s seas

    Countries across the EU are failing to punish illegal fishing activities and not enforcing fisheries laws properly, new research by ClientEarth finds today.

  • Two orca fins in black water

    Can eco-labels really save our marine life?

    The EU and the UK have introduced new measures to stop the growing amount of plastics ending up in our oceans. But how much will this help the growing crisis affecting our marine life?

  • Close up of blue and white fishing net for story saying New North Sea fisheries management plan confirms sustainability is a top priority

    New North Sea fisheries management plan confirms sustainability is a top priority

    Fisheries in the North Sea received a boost today, as European Parliament voted for catches to be sustainable at all times under a new management plan.

  • Follow us

    You can help

    Your support helps us use the law to protect your environment.