Woman in yellow coat by red train for story saying New UN report is damning on UK environmental justice

New UN report criticises UK environmental justice

A new UN report has criticised the UK’s record on court access for people bringing environmental cases.

The Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee said the UK’s recent law reforms have ‘moved it further away’ from fulfilling its duty to let citizens go to court to protect their environment. It also reprimanded the UK for slow progress to date. The UK has not only dragged its feet, its compliance is actually now worse thanks to new court rules introduced in February this year.

ClientEarth lawyer Gillian Lobo said: “This report confirms that the UK is breaching its responsibility under international law, the Aarhus Convention, by failing to provide access to justice in environmental cases. It has been in breach for years, and recent reforms have made it even harder to go to court over issues like dirty air, polluting factories or endangered wildlife. The UK must act now to let people use the courts to protect their environment.”

The Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee first found the UK’s costs to be prohibitively expensive in 2014, after a complaint brought by ClientEarth, the Marine Conservation Society and Robert Latimer.

ClientEarth, Friends of the Earth and the RSPB took the UK government to court on 19 July 2017 over the new rules, which will have a chilling effect on environment legal cases. Since February this year, some legal costs can now can be changed at any stage in the proceedings. This means it is impossible to know how much a case will cost from the start, which is likely to deter people who want to go to court to protect the environment.

The campaigners call on the UK government to ensure environmental cases are not prohibitively expensive, and to remove or reduce financial and other barriers to justice.

David Wolfe QC and Andrew Parkinson represented the three organisations.

The judgment is expected this month.

Share this...
Share on Facebook! Tweet this! Share on LinkedIn! Email!


Related articles

More from

  • passenger

    ClientEarth launches legal action to avert another Dieselgate

    New rules which allow car manufacturers to keep their emissions control systems secret from the public risk another Dieselgate scandal.

  • ClientEArth: Chairty Times Charity of the Year

    ClientEarth celebrates wins, recognition and rankings surge at FT and Charity Times awards

    Environmental law teams across ClientEarth are celebrating this morning following recognition at two major awards ceremonies last night, in multiple categories.

  • timber planks across grass

    EU abandons leadership on access to justice on international stage

    The EU’s proposal not to adopt the UN’s findings that it is breaching international law by blocking EU court access in environmental matters has been rejected.

  • london eye

    Victory for UK environment as judge says cost rules must change

    Today’s victory means that claimants will no longer have to expose their private financial details in open court when applying for judicial review.

  • Follow us


    Get our regular email newsletters, they contain the latest updates on our work as well as features and articles about environmental issues, science and politics.