Mountains reflected in a lake with trees and a white house on the lake edge

House of Lords warning over Brexit and environmental laws

A committee of the House of Lords has said that leaving the EU will have a significant impact on environment and climate change policies in the UK.

In a report ‘Brexit: environment and climate change’ published today, the committee has found that maintaining existing standards of environmental protection through the Great Repeal Bill will be an immensely difficult task, given the complex and extensive nature of environmental legislation.

ClientEarth biodiversity lawyer Catherine Weller said:

“The House of Lords has confirmed the immense risk to the UK environment posed by Brexit. Maintaining existing standards through the Great Repeal Bill will be a hugely complex task.”

“As a first step, the government must enshrine current environmental protections in law – we’ll be watching closely to ensure that they do this and they don’t sneak in a way to undo these protections overnight.”

The report also found that ‘a risk of a vacuum’ may exist once the EU institutions (the European Commission and European Court of Justice) no longer have oversight or enforcement of environmental laws.

These institutions have had a major impact on the UK’s compliance in the past. The government seems to be worryingly complacent about the loss of this enforcement regime. As such, the committee has recommended that an independent enforcement mechanism will be needed to fill this vacuum.

Weller added:

“The Lords rightly highlighted the danger of a lack of oversight and enforcement once the UK leaves the EU. We agree that a strong, independent domestic mechanism is crucial to make sure effective environmental laws are made and followed.”

“This mechanism must be underpinned by judicial oversight. People must be able to go to court to defend the environment. This is the only way to make sure the environmental gains of the last 40 years are not lost – the best way to protect people and the planet.”

The EU is the source of the majority of environmental legislation in the UK. This means that leaving the EU will have a significant impact on environment and climate change policies in the UK.

ClientEarth will continue to fight for strong environmental laws after the UK leaves the European Union.

Share this...
Share on Facebook! Tweet this! Share on LinkedIn! Email!

Jim Monk

Related articles

More from or

  • Bialowieza Forest tree trunk

    15 judges at the EU’s highest court to rule on illegal logging in Białowieża Forest

    Judges from the EU’s highest Court have heard arguments from Poland’s Environment Minister and the EU Commission on illegal logging in Białowieża Forest.

  • Two orca fins in black water

    Can eco-labels really save our marine life?

    The EU and the UK have introduced new measures to stop the growing amount of plastics ending up in our oceans. But how much will this help the growing crisis affecting our marine life?

  • running in autumn forest for story saying interim fines requested in legal fight over Bialowieza Forest

    Commission calls for fines as European Court of Justice hears case over illegal logging in Bialowieza Forest

    The Commission has today called on the EU’s most senior judges to impose fines on the Polish side for illegal logging in Bialowieza Forest, as the European Court of Justice was deliberating whether an emergency ban on logging in should be upheld.

  • swans in the evening light

    Polish new Water Law remains detrimental for environment

    A new Water Law was signed this month by the Polish president. It is a response to the 2016 Court of Justice ruling that Poland had failed to implement Water Framework Directive. Although this new piece of legislation was meant to fully implement the EU law, it contains provisions that are likely to have a largely negative impact on the environment.

  • Follow us

    You can help

    Your support helps us use the law to protect your environment.