Dover cliffs for story saying Government protection plan for vulnerable marine ecosystem falls short

UK Government protection plan for vulnerable marine ecosystem falls short

Proposed plans to protect vulnerable marine areas off the coast of Kent fall short and would set a bad precedent for the waters around the UK.

The Marine Management Organisation (MMO) is proposing measures to protect Margate and Longsands Special Area of Conservation from potentially damaging fishing. The site was designated for protection due to sandbank habitat – this provides important feeding habitat for seabirds and also nursery grounds for many fish species.

This proposal is part of the UK Government’s “Revised Approach” to fisheries management in English marine protected sites. It has committed to bring these sites in line with EU law by the end of 2016 – assessing the impacts of fishing activities on the habitats and species in protected areas and implementing management measures where needed.

ClientEarth lawyer Alice Puritz said: “The Margate and Longsands proposals do not go far enough – they don’t protect sensitive habitats from bottom-towed fishing and it’s not clear they respect the law. Continual disturbance of the seabed from these activities will create biodiversity deserts dominated by a small number of organisms that can withstand such conditions.

“This has a negative impact on the creatures that depend on healthy, diverse ecosystems for their survival – like fish, seals and seabirds. Diverse ecosystems are good for nature as well as the fishing industry.”

This case is particularly important because it could set a precedent for future UK decisions about fisheries management measures in those protected sites which have mainly sandbank habitats.

The proposal takes a zoned approach to managing fishing in the site, closing off only two small areas to bottom-towed fishing, while two large areas of sensitive habitat remain exposed.

The inadequacy of this proposal is brought into sharp relief by inconsistencies in Natural England’s (NE) conservation advice in relation to the site. NE has said that areas of certain habitat types in the inshore area of the site should be protected, while in the offshore area the advice is that the very same habitat type does not need to be protected. It is difficult to understand the logic behind this approach. A zoned approach to management is also harder to monitor and enforce.

ClientEarth analysis shows the entire site should be closed to bottom-towed fishing. This is the only way to comply with EU law protecting delicate ecosystems. At the very least, the closures should be extended to include all sensitive habitat types.

Read ClientEarth’s consultation response to the Marine Management Organisation’s proposals for the management of fishing activities in Margate and Longsands Special Area of Conservation.

Share this...
Share on Facebook! Tweet this! Share on LinkedIn! Email!

David Hollman

Related articles

More from

  • Fishing boat at sunset for story saying Commission 2018 fishing quotas risk missing legal sustainability deadline

    Commission’s 2018 fishing quotas risk missing legal sustainability deadline

    Many of the Commission’s proposed 2018 Northeast Atlantic fishing quotas move in the right direction, but the EU is still likely to miss 2020 deadline for sustainable fishing.

  • yellow and green flowers with fishing boat on sea

    Half-hearted sanctions against illegal fishing threaten Europe’s seas

    Countries across the EU are failing to punish illegal fishing activities and not enforcing fisheries laws properly, new research by ClientEarth finds today.

  • Two orca fins in black water

    Can eco-labels really save our marine life?

    The EU and the UK have introduced new measures to stop the growing amount of plastics ending up in our oceans. But how much will this help the growing crisis affecting our marine life?

  • Close up of blue and white fishing net for story saying New North Sea fisheries management plan confirms sustainability is a top priority

    New North Sea fisheries management plan confirms sustainability is a top priority

    Fisheries in the North Sea received a boost today, as European Parliament voted for catches to be sustainable at all times under a new management plan.

  • Follow us

    You can help

    Your support helps us use the law to protect your environment.